Contact us
Product Huntlaunching December 5 Follow the launch

Research · 6 min read

Do people hate AI commercials? We analyzed 4,549 YouTube comments

Most commenters do. Under the official YouTube uploads of seven AI-generated commercials, 82% of comments that judged the ad were negative, against 34% under ordinary ads from the same channels. Viewers called the ads soulless and cheap far more often than they pointed at glitches.

A silver film reel on a dark round plinth, with blank speech bubbles above it in gray and ink and one drawn as a thin green outline

Key takeaways

  • Under the official YouTube uploads of seven AI-generated commercials, 925 of 1,123 comments that judged the ad were negative (82%). Under seven ordinary ads from the same brand channels, 93 of 274 were (34%).
  • None of the seven official titles mentioned AI, yet viewers named it in 32% of the comments. Under the ordinary ads from the same channels, 3.5% did.
  • Soulless, cheap and lazy led the complaints: 33% of 951 negative comments. Visual errors and uncanny people together came to 12%.
  • Brands switched comments off on 6 of 19 official uploads of AI ads we found. On the same channels' other videos from six months either side, 142 of 2,174 had comments off.
  • The exception was Google's AI turkey: 47% of opinions on it were negative, close to the 44% under two earlier ads of the same campaign.

Brands now run AI-generated commercials in their biggest seasonal campaigns, at the Super Bowl and on national TV. Surveys ask people what they think of such ads in general. We wanted to see what viewers say about specific ones, so we analyzed the comments under them on YouTube and compared them with comments under the same brands’ ordinary ads.

Do people hate AI-generated commercials?

Most of the people who comment on them do. Under the official YouTube uploads of seven AI-generated commercials, 925 of 1,123 comments that judged the ad were negative (82%). Under seven ordinary ads from the same brand channels, 93 of 274 were (34%). Taken ad by ad, the median was 66% negative for AI ads and 31% for ordinary ones.

Data table
Brand and AI commercialOrdinary ads, same channelAI-generated ad
Coca-Cola (Holidays Are Coming, 2025)33% of 19089% of 447
Vodafone Germany (The Rhythm of Life, 2024)44% of 2784% of 32
Under Armour (Forever Is Made Now, 2024)0% of 1458% of 55
Google (Just Ask Google, turkey, 2025)44% of 4347% of 57
Coca-Cola (Holidays Are Coming, 2024, agency upload)—89% of 411
Spreequell (Kräuterbrause, 2025)—66% of 79
KPN (Christmas with Louis, 2025)—64% of 42
Share of comments that judged the ad and were negative, on each brand's official YouTube upload. Gray ring: ordinary ads from the same channel, pooled; orange dot: the AI-generated ad. Rows without a ring had no ordinary ad with enough comments on the same channel. Up to 600 top comments per video, collected on November 22, 2026. Quelta analysis.

The gap held for three of the four brands where we had an ordinary ad to compare, though the samples for Vodafone and Under Armour are small. Coca-Cola’s 2025 “Holidays Are Coming” drew 396 negative comments out of 447 that judged it (89%), against 33% under two of Coca-Cola’s ordinary ads on the same channel. Vodafone Germany’s AI film “The Rhythm of Life” drew 84%, against 44% under its ordinary TV spots. Under Armour’s ordinary ad drew 14 opinions, none negative. Google was the exception, and we come back to it below.

Other viewers agreed with the critics. Under the median AI ad, 94% of the likes on comments that judged the ad went to negative ones. Under the median ordinary ad, 48% did.

Do viewers notice when a commercial is AI-generated?

Yes, and they say so. None of the seven official uploads mentioned AI in its title, yet viewers named AI in 465 of 1,445 comments under them (32%). Under the ordinary ads from the same channels, 23 of 658 comments did (3.5%). Some spotted it in the footage, others had read about it in the news; the comments rarely say which.

A label in the title changed little. The same Coca-Cola 2024 film drew 89% negative opinions on its agency’s official upload, which does not mention AI, and 86% under four re-uploads titled “AI-Generated” (1,196 opinions). That matches a May 2026 study by MediaScience and the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute: across 900 US viewers, four kinds of AI labels caused no significant change in brand choice, ad memory or ad liking. Where platforms require a label, our guide to AI labels on TikTok, Meta and YouTube shows what triggers one.

What do viewers dislike about AI commercials?

Most often that they feel soulless, not that they look wrong. Of 951 negative or mixed comments under the official uploads, 312 (33%) called the ad soulless, cheap, lazy or “slop”. 136 (14%) said the brand had replaced artists, actors or crews, and 130 (14%) said they would stop buying it. Visual errors and uncanny people together came to 112 comments (12%).

Data table
What the comment criticizesCommentsOfPercent
Soulless, cheap, lazy, "slop"31295132.8%
Dislike with no reason given29795131.2%
Replaced artists, actors or crews13695114.3%
Won't buy, boycott the brand13095113.7%
Visual errors: morphing, physics, wrong details799518.3%
The original ad was better419514.3%
Creepy or uncanny people and faces339513.5%
Story, editing or music289512.9%
Reasons given in 951 negative or mixed comments under the official YouTube uploads of seven AI-generated commercials. A comment can give more than one reason. Orange: complaints about how the footage looks. Collected on November 22, 2026. Quelta analysis.

Praise was rarer, and the reason it named most often was the look. Of 198 positive or mixed comments, 42 (21%) praised the visuals, 37 (19%) the warm, festive feeling and 20 (10%) what the technology can do.

That is our reading of the numbers: viewers judge an AI commercial as a decision the brand made, not as a piece of footage. A glitch can be fixed in the next render. The sense that the brand didn’t want to pay people can’t.

Why did people dislike the Coca-Cola AI Christmas ad?

Mostly because it felt soulless, and viewers held it up against a film they love. “Holidays Are Coming”, with its lit-up trucks, first aired in the 1990s; Coca-Cola remade it with generative AI in 2024 and again in 2025. Both remakes drew 89% negative opinions on their official uploads, out of 447 and 411 comments that judged them. 98% and 99% of the likes on those comments went to the negative ones.

The remakes also sent viewers back to the old film. Under the live-action 2020 version on Coca-Cola Great Britain & Ireland’s channel, none of the 49 comments written in 2020⁠–⁠2023 mention AI. 51 of the 134 written since 2024 do. “Came back to this after seeing the AI slopfest that is the new advert,” one of them reads.

The 2025 film had 3.2 million views and 12,243 comments on Coca-Cola’s main channel when we collected the data.

Do brands switch off comments on AI ads?

Often. Of the 19 official uploads of AI-generated commercials we found, 6 had comments switched off. On the same channels’ other videos from six months either side, 142 of 2,174 had them off (6.5%), and 20 of 1,637 (1.2%) without one Brazilian car channel that turns comments off on many of its videos.

Data table
CommentsComments or videosOfPercent
Comments that name AI: Official uploads of 7 AI ads465144532.2%
Comments that name AI: Ordinary ads from the same channels236583.5%
Comments switched off: Official uploads of AI ads61931.6%
Comments switched off: Other videos on the same channels, ±6 months14221746.5%
Comments switched off: The same, without one channel that disables widely (GWM Brasil left out)2016371.2%
Top: share of comments that name AI, under the official uploads of seven AI-generated commercials and under ordinary ads from the same channels. Bottom: share of videos with comments switched off, for 19 official uploads of AI-generated ads and for the same channels' other videos from six months before to six months after each AI ad. Checked on November 22, 2026. Quelta analysis.

Three brands switched comments off only on the AI ad. Deutsche Telekom kept comments open on all 107 of its other videos from those months, and turned them off on its 2026 AI Christmas film “Take Time to Connect”. Toys“R”Us and Coign did the same: 0 of 5 and 0 of 37 other videos had comments off.

Switching comments off does not always end the conversation. McDonald’s Netherlands pulled its AI Christmas ad in December 2025, days after it came out. A re-upload titled as an AI-generated ad collected 409 comments, and 86% of the 328 that judged the ad were negative.

Which AI commercials did viewers accept?

The ones that did not pretend to be a film shoot with real people. Google’s “Planning a Quick Getaway?”, which 9to5Google reported was made entirely with generative AI, stars a turkey named Tom planning a getaway before Thanksgiving. 47% of the 57 comments that judged it were negative, close to the 44% of 43 under two earlier ads of the same “Just Ask Google” campaign.

KPN’s Christmas ad with a cat named Louis drew 64% negative opinions out of 42. Together, the two ads with no people on screen drew 55% negative opinions out of 99. The ads with people drew 84%. Two ads are too few to make a rule, but the pattern fits a 2026 Bentley-Gallup poll: 62% of 3,270 US adults said AI-created people or voices in ads are unacceptable even when disclosed.

Does an AI-generated ad hurt the brand?

Surveys say it can. In the Bentley-Gallup poll, 49% of US adults viewed businesses that use AI to create ads negatively and 19% positively. The IAB found in January 2026 that 82% of advertising executives think consumers feel positive about AI ads, while 45% of Gen Z and Millennial consumers do. In an Ipsos and Syracuse University test of 20 ads with 3,000 US consumers, the ads made by people were 14% stronger on short-term effectiveness and 17% stronger on long-term. In Australia, 45% told YouGov they would trust a brand less if its ads were made mainly with AI.

Comments are not sales, and we measured only what viewers wrote. They do show that a showcase can backfire in public: Kalshi’s NBA Finals spot, posted by its director with “AI” in the title, drew 81% negative opinions out of 257.

How to check an AI commercial before it airs

Run the six checks below before the ad goes on air. Each is drawn from the comments we analyzed and the studies above; the checks on people and new ideas rest on two ads only.

Tick each check the video passes.
Six checks before an AI-generated commercial goes on air, from 4,549 YouTube comments we analyzed. Tick the ones your ad passes.

We make TV commercials and screen ads on our engine, without a shoot, with the real product as the reference. Examples are on our page about TV commercials and screen ads without a shoot, and our check of what a filmed TV commercial costs in Europe puts the alternative in numbers. If you want to test it on your own ad, we start with a pilot.

Sources

  1. Quelta analysis of YouTube comments on AI-generated and ordinary commercials, November 22, 2026: one row per video, without comment texts (CSV)
  2. Quelta check of comment settings on 19 official uploads of AI-generated commercials and 2,174 other videos on the same channels (CSV)
  3. YouTube Data API, CommentThreads: list
  4. Gallup, Americans Aren't Sold on Businesses Using AI in Advertising (August 19, 2026)
  5. IAB, The AI Ad Gap Widens (January 15, 2026)
  6. Ipsos, AI ads are good enough, and that's the problem (May 2026)
  7. YouGov, 45% of Australians say AI-generated ads would make them trust a brand less (May 2026)
  8. MediaScience and Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, Study: AI labeling does not hurt video ad performance (May 21, 2026)
  9. Nielsen Norman Group, Why AI-Generated Holiday Ads Fail (December 19, 2025)
  10. LBB Online, Coca-Cola's AI Christmas ad, Holidays Are Coming (November 15, 2024)
  11. 9to5Google, This is Google's first AI-generated TV ad (October 31, 2025)
  12. TechRadar, McDonald's pulls AI-generated Christmas ad after backlash (December 2025)
  13. heise online, Berlin agency implements commercial entirely with AI (June 17, 2025)
  14. Ads of the World, Deutsche Telekom: Take Time to Connect (November 2026)
  15. Euronews, Under Armour's AI-powered sports commercial sparks controversy (March 15, 2024)
  16. Muse by Clios, Does Vodafone's Rhythm of Life chart a future for AI ads? (December 18, 2024)
  17. No Film School, Toys 'R' Us is first brand to produce fully AI-generated commercial (June 26, 2024)
  18. NPR, An AI video ad is making a splash. Is it the future of advertising? (June 23, 2025)

Quelta for catalogs

Need videos like this for your whole catalog?

Quelta makes product videos from your photos, adapted for each of your markets by meaning, not just by words, and checked before delivery. Start with a pilot on one category.

Start with a pilot

Tell us about your catalog

Send a link to your catalog or website and tell us roughly how many videos you need a month. We start with a pilot on 3⁠–⁠5 of your products, so you can judge the videos on your own catalog.

  1. Send a link to your catalog

    Your website, a product feed or your store on a marketplace.

  2. We make a pilot on 3⁠–⁠5 of your products

    Product-accurate videos of your real products, for the markets and platforms you need.

  3. A monthly contract for the volume you need

    New videos for the catalog and new arrivals every month, in one style.

We don’t copy other people’s videos. Every video is new and about your product. We keep the mechanics that sell (script, pacing, delivery), not anyone’s footage, people or music.

Contact us

Prefer to talk first? Yegor, Co-founder. A 30-minute video call about your catalog.

Book a call

Made with our engineTests, not client projects

Questions and answers

Do people hate AI-generated commercials?

Most people who comment on them do. In our November 2026 analysis of 4,549 YouTube comments, 82% of the comments that judged seven officially uploaded AI-generated commercials were negative, against 34% for ordinary ads from the same brand channels. Surveys point the same way: in a 2026 Bentley-Gallup poll of 3,270 US adults, 49% viewed businesses using AI to create ads negatively and 19% positively.

Why did people dislike the Coca-Cola AI Christmas ad?

Mostly because it felt soulless to viewers, and they held it up against a film they love, not because of visible errors. 89% of the comments that judged Coca-Cola's official 2025 upload were negative, and 98% of the likes on those comments went to the negative ones. Viewers also went back to the 2020 live-action version: 51 of 134 comments written there since 2024 mention AI, against none of 49 written before.

Do viewers notice when a commercial is AI-generated?

Many do, or have read about it. None of the seven official uploads we analyzed mentioned AI in the title, yet 32% of the comments under them named AI. Under ordinary ads from the same channels, 3.5% of comments did.

Does labeling an ad as AI-generated make the reaction worse?

Not in our data. The same Coca-Cola 2024 film drew 89% negative opinions on its agency's official upload and 86% under four re-uploads titled AI-Generated. A May 2026 study of 900 US viewers by MediaScience and the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute also reported, in a press release, no significant difference in brand choice, ad memory or ad liking across four kinds of AI labels.

Why do brands turn off comments on AI ads?

Brands don't say, but they do it often. Of 19 official uploads of AI-generated commercials we found, 6 had comments switched off, against 142 of 2,174 other videos on the same channels in the same months. Deutsche Telekom, Toys"R"Us and Coign switched comments off only on their AI ad. In McDonald's Netherlands' case, the conversation moved to a re-upload.